Thursday, February 9, 2012

Review: Zveda Panzer II

by SandWyrm


So there I was at Hobbytown USA, fruitlessly looking for more Tamaya desert-colored spraypaint, when I accidentally found that they carry 1/100 Zveda sets! Mostly it was Soviet Armor, with a few planes and rocket trucks. But they did have a couple of German vehicles such as the Pz38 and the PzII. So I grabbed a Panzer II and brought it home. What did I get for my $5.00?



Here's the front of the box...


...and the back. Obviously, it's quite Russian. :)


In contrast the the Plastic Soldier Company kits, it's super-simple to assemble. There's only 5 pieces. Trimming and gluing only took a couple of minutes.


The shocker though, was the scale compared to my Battlefront PzII's. It's tiny!


The small Zveda details are sharper and more accurate. While Battlefront gets the large details more correct.

Or maybe the Zveda is Ausf-A, while the Battlefront Mini is Ausf-F. But this design started out as a training tank. The Germans upgraded the ones they had, but didn't build new ones after the war started. So there shouldn't be a big size difference between the versions.

Let's look again at the scale...


Here's a pic of a real PzII next to what looks like a PzIII or IV (same height either way), with a King Tiger in the far left background. You can see that the PzII has a noticeably lower deck than the Panzer it's next to.


If I put the Zveda PzII next to my Plastic Soldier Company PzIV, you see a similar difference. While the Battlefront PzII has the same deck height.


But is it really that low? The deck on the Zveda PzII is about the same height as a Kübelwagen!

Consulting Wikipedia, the Panzer II's dimensions are listed as 4.38 m(l) x 2.14 m(w) x 1.95 m(h). So pulling out a metric ruler, I measured the models. At 1/100 scale, they should be 4.38cm x 2.14cm x 1.95cm.

Battlefront PzII:

4.7cm x 2.3cm x 2.2cm

So it's 7.3% too long, 7.5% too wide, and 12.8% too high.

Zveda PzII:

4.3cm x 2.05cm x 1.8cm (if it had a cupola)

That's 1.8% less long, 4.2% less wide, and 7.6% too short.

So a properly scaled PzII would be somewhere between these two models. Just on the smaller side of half-way.

At least it was only $5. :)

7 comments:

  1. It's probably a ploy to stop people from mixing and matching from competing brands.

    ReplyDelete
  2. They all look like mm differences. I'll be honest, it is all metal boxes to me.
    Sigh, there is a reason I play Tyranids.

    ReplyDelete
  3. They sell them in boxes of one?
    0_o

    Do you suppose it would make a difference to someone, seeing a bunch of these across the table?

    Btw, my 3rd edition rulebook is in hand....

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't think it would be an issue as long as your platoon is all of one type or the other. And as long as your opponents don't mind that the Zveda PzII is of an earlier type with no cupola and different gear on the deck.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Got a rogue question related to this, can you use the Zveda, PSC and Battlefront Mini's to all play FoW without any trouble?

    I'm thinking about getting into it from a hobby aspect and when I finally get around to playing have some stuff that is useable on the table as well.

    Great looking kits though, I love WWII AFV's.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes! As long as the scale and tank version match up, you can use minis from any manufacturer to play.

    ReplyDelete

Recent Favorites

All-Time Favorites