Sunday, February 26, 2012

Battle Report: German Panzers vs. Russian Infantry

by SandWyrm

Jerry, the owner/manager of Games 2D4 offered me a game this week, so I put together a 2K mid-war list and headed over the the store on Saturday. Jerry has been playing Russians lately, so I wasn't too surprised to see him pull out a big Red Army infantry list when I got there. Having already faced the T-34 onslaught earlier this week, I was eager to see what it was like to face a big Russian infantry horde at 2000 points.

Here's the list I brought with me:

Sandwyrm's Afrika Panzerkompanie

145    1iC: Panzer IV F2
115    2iC: Panzer III L
    5    Recovery Half Track
Combat Platoons
    Panzer Platoon
580    4 Panzer IV F2
    Panzer Platoon
400    4 Panzer IV F1
    Light Panzer Platoon
150    3 Panzer II F
Support Platoons
    Schwere Panzer Platoon
385    Tiger 1E
    Rocket Launcher Platoon
220    6 NW41 Launchers

Total: 2000 Points

This is a similar list to the one I faced the T-34's with. It's got a Tiger for holding down the flank, a unit of F2's for long range sniping, some F1's for close-in work, some PzII's for scouting out ambushes, and a big unit of Nebelwerfers for both pinning down enemy infantry and smoking positions.

I had 5 points left over, so I brought a recovery vehicle along too. In theory it might come in useful for pulling a tank out of difficult terrain that it's gotten bogged down in. But it's usually more of a comic relief choice, as Farmpunk can never seem to kill the thing. Not with tank fire or with air strikes. :)

Jerry's Red Army Strelkovy Battalion

Yikes! Just one of those infantry platoons companies has more models in it than my entire army! He also has some fearsome long-range anti-tank units in there. Plus some heavily armored KV flame tanks. Well, at least I don't have any infantry to worry about. :)


We rolled up a 'No Retreat' battle.

In this type of battle, there's two objectives on the table. One placed by the attacker and one by the defender. The attacker has to capture one. The defender is trying to hold the attacker off with a reduced number of units until reinforcements arrive. They win if the attacker loses enough units to fail a company morale check, or if the attacker has no units in the defender's deployment zone from turn 6 on.

To balance things, the defender gets half of their forces (rounded down) on the table at the start of the game; up to half (rounded down) of which can be placed in ambush. The rest of the defender's units go in reserve. While the attacker gets to put all of their forces on the table after the defender has deployed.


Here's our table after deployment. Infantry always defends against tanks, so Jerry put his objective in the rear, while I placed mine up front behind the road. He took the side with the buildings because it's easier to defend.

Jerry has strung a platoon company of infantry right across the table. Yep, that's all ONE unit.

Behind them he's placed his artillery in a deliberately messy formation that I'll have trouble hitting much of at once with my own artillery. That many guns is plenty scary.

His SU-152's go into ambush. They have the firepower to easily destroy my Tiger, much less the many light and medium tanks I have. :(

I go all-in on the right side where the objective is closer. With my artillery in back to support. There's a spotter right there in the trees...

...and another one over on the other side. So I can spot pretty much anything on the table.

For my Tiger's skill, I roll up 'For The Fatherland!', which gives him a 2+ morale (normally 4+). Oh well... I was hoping for shooting re-rolls or another shot on the main gun. I put him in the trees since he passes terrain tests easily. He's there to hold down my flank against everything Jerry has on the other side of the table.

It teases, yes it does. But there's an anti-tank gun and 2 anti-tank rifle teams to worry about first. Not to mention the SU-152's that will pop out somewhere. How am I going to dig out all that infantry?

Let's get on with it.

My Rocket Artillery opens up. I'm not sure whether to shoot at Jerry's dug-in artillery or just pummel the dug-in infantry I'm facing. But I end up going with the infantry. I need to pin them down and maybe kill a few.

(The smoke puffs, btw, are there to mark that I've fired. One disadvantage of Nebelwerfers is that they leave a nice big plume of smoke in the sky that gives away their position to the enemy. Such that Jerry will be able to range in on them with his artillery without the need for LOS from a spotter. )

Dug-In infantry are VERY hard to kill. They get a 3+ save right off the bat, and even if they fail you have to roll a firepower test to actually kill the team. So despite a rocket barrage and lots of shots from the rest of my army, I only actually killed ONE team!

At least I got a smoke hit with an F1 that made the anti-tank gun much less of a threat. Now he can only see 16" and has a 2 point penalty to hit.

I surprised Jerry with this, as he didn't know that direct-fire smoke didn't have to be fired at the beginning of the turn anymore. In 3rd Edition, it just has to be fired before the other shots in the same platoon.

On his turn, Jerry's 2nd company of infantry comes on. Oh boy... I've barely damaged his first line and now I have to worry about reinforcements?

That massive artillery battery opens up and... only kills one rocket launcher. I breath a sigh of relief, but losing a launcher does mean that I won't be able to fire double-width templates anymore. :(

Alright, turn two. I move forward cautiously and shoot again.

My whole army fires and I kill one anti-tank rifle team. This isn't working. I should have assaulted instead!

Jerry's infantry reinforcements plod forward. If it weren't for the threat of my artillery, they'd probably be running instead. Because if they ran, I'd get double dice when rolling to hit them. :)

Over on the left by the artillery, his SU-76M's come on and high-tail it for the middle of the table.

The SU-152's pop out of ambush behind the road. They each get a single AP13 1+ firepower shot (with re-rolls) that will auto-kill anything I have but the Tiger.

Jerry would like to kill my F2's up on the hill, but he's just out of range. So he shoots at my PzII's instead. Why the PzII's? Because he wanted to kill a platoon, and they were the smallest. Remember that he's trying to wear me down until I fail a company morale check and run. To do that, he needs to kill 3 of my 5 platoons and preferably my 1iC and 2iC as well.

But he only hits one PzII. No morale test. Awe. :)


It's do or die time. I move up and prepare to assault. Fortunately I manage to take out the anti-tank gun and the last anti-tank rifle that can see me. So Jerry won't have anything too nasty left when he gets his defensive fire.

I learned A LOT about assaulting in this battle. Previously, I'd always just moved every tank into assault together like you would with infantry in 40K, but Jerry took me through the proper procedure very patiently. It's one platoon at a time. You assault, play it to completion, and then you assault with the next platoon.

So in went the F1's and my 2iC in the PzIII.

They took out about about a third of the enemy troops before I failed a morale check and was forced to disengage. Any units left within 4" of the enemy after consolidating are automatically destroyed. So my bailed-out F1 was toast.

In went the PzII's.

Whenever Jerry failed a morale check, his 1iC gave him a re-roll. If he failed that, his Kommissar would execute a squad and give him a 2nd re-roll. The Kommissar would kill a lot of men this game!

The PzII's kill a few bases before falling back and losing a bailed out tank. That leaves...


Now, regular infantry can't hurt a Tiger in close combat. But if they hit at least once I do have to make a morale check or be forced to disengage. Remember that 2+ morale skill that I wasn't so crazy about? Well it worked wonders here. Instead of a 4+ morale, I was even more fanatical than the Russians and their 3+!

I kept rolling ones (10 in 12 rounds) to hit in that assault, but I never rolled a 1 for morale.

Eventually, after I killed 2 infantry and Jerry's Kommissar had killed 3, he broke off. The Tiger had forced his line back up the hill all by himself!

(You're getting painted first buddy!)

Things have started looking a bit better for the Wehrmacht.

Look though, Jerry's KV's have come on. Why are they over by his artillery? Their guns aren't great (AP7), but they have Tiger-class armor on them. I would have brought them in behind the infantry to help contest the objective.

Those SU-152's are still in a great position though. They shoot and pop 2 of my remaining F1's. These guys really need to die soon.

I move up the F2's and open fire on the SU's. I kill one.

My 2iC (over on the objective) in his PzIII kills the other. Nice.

That Russian artillery spotter next to the objective is an independent team, so he can't hold or contest the objective. Hence, I ignore him in lieu of other targets. The Russian artillery barrages keep coming down, but they're not killing anything.

I assault the Kommissar and kill him. The rest of Jerry's infantry break off. The Tiger consolidates into a defensive position on the road. I have the objective.

But will I keep it? The 2nd line of infantry has moved up within range to contest. Jerry considers assaulting me, but is afraid of the defensive fire from 7 tanks.

The SU-85M's make it up onto the center hill for some side shots. Jerry uses them to kill my last 2 F1's.

In return, my Tiger takes out two of them. Gotta love that 88.

If I hadn't taken a turn too long to do the initial assault, I wouldn't have had to worry about this 2nd line of infantry. But I didn't and they're here. Time to prepare for the assault! The dice you see are my machine gun hits. Believe it or not, Jerry only failed 3 of these saves!

In go the F2's, backed up by by both the 1iC and the 2iC.

By the time I finally fail a morale check and pull back (losing the 2iC), I've almost wiped out the entire company! That's insanely good luck!

At the cost of one tank, I killed 25 infantry bases!

In goes the last PzII to try and clean up.

And he does!

Jerry's unit then fails their morale check and runs off the table. He has nothing left that he can hope to contest with.

The SU-85M's kill 2 F2's in a last-ditch effort to make my platoon flee, but they pass their morale check. The KV's try and kill my PzII, but miss all of their shots.


In our exuberance, we decide to let the observer team walk home without shoes. :)

Army Lessons Learned
  1. If I have an infantry unit pinned and smoked, GO AHEAD AND ASSAULT!  Don't wait!
  2. Always bring a Tiger along. They can handle the unexpected.
  3. I Need More PzII's.
  4. I don't need more than 4 Artillery pieces in a unit.
I could have saved 80 points by taking 4 Nebelwerfers instead of 6. I could have then saved 20 more points by dropping the Recovery vehicle and giving the 2iC an F1 to ride around in instead of the PzIII L. With that 100 points, I can take 2 more PzII's. Which are just too damn useful. Both as a recon unit (to limit ambushes) and as a cheap infantry assault unit.

Jerry told me that this wasn't the hardest list he could have fought me with. Next time I can expect that 2nd line of infantry to be Pioneers (Engineer Troops). Against engineers, I'd have 4+ saves in combat instead of 2+ saves. While the Tiger would need a 3+. Big difference!

All in all, it was a fun battle that I went into with a lot of uncertainty. With no small bit of luck though, I was able to win the day!

Thanks Jerry!


  1. Thanks for the report, looks like it was fun.

    It was a bit confusing reading about the Germans fighting Jerry though!

    1. He used to play Germans, if that makes you feel better.

  2. The more I see the more I want in. Thanks for the write-up.

    1. You DO love Tanks, don'tcha buddy?

      Join us....join us....

  3. Great batrep fella. Just a rules correction, running incurs double dice from direct fire weapons, but NOT from artillery. I played an identical game as my first big game and made the same mistake ... tanks are actually better (?!) in assault than shooting because most infantry can't do anything against them. My list usually includes a lot more 57mm Antitank guns. 36" range, 3 shots and AT11 - they rock anything and would have made very short work of any tanks coming onto the board. I play late war, so I'm keener on the SU100 than the SU152, less antipersonnel utility, but at Armour 9, AT16 and 40" range, it's a tiger (and panther) killer. 230pts for three - yes please!

    1. Correction noted. Thanks!

      I was originally going to try a late-war list. But I didn't have enough late-war stuff for a decent 1575 game. So we just went with a big mid-war battle instead.

    2. SU100s? Yes please. They're the next thing I grab after I get some Kates (Katyushas).

    3. Can't use SU-100's in mid-war.

  4. Now you understand why I love Tigers so much.
    They're the rock stars of my army.

    A lotta folks like Panthers, but side armor 5 really hurts them- defensive fire from Bazookas and stuff.
    Also, they're top armor 1, not 2.
    Tigers are cheaper, can be bought individually in a lot of lists (Panthers have to be purchased in lots of 3, and are FAR better in assault.

    Dirty, filthy Russians.
    Rotten peasants.
    Good to see them die.

  5. Generally no infantry platoon wants to assault tanks. Beating up on one tank off by it's self, sure. But 4-5 tanks in defensive fire range is too many machine guns to hope miss. It's pretty bad to get yourself pinned on your turn.

  6. First. SU-76M not SU-85M. Jerry should have keyed on the closer objective as the farther one would be easy to reinforce. I am assuming Jerry's Soviets were all dug in as the scenario includes having troops start dug-in (and gone to ground if you are smart). The Soviet artillery is also not positioned to cover the closest objective. Soviets can fire the 122mm howitzers as artillery while using the ZIS-3 as AT weapons. R32 RoF2 AT9 FP3+ is pretty good in mid-war. Re-roll misses under 16" (effective July 43 and after IMHO). Agree his KV should have come in to directly counter-attack your tank company and he ambushed too soon. I think I would have placed the two 45mm ATG dug-in in the woods next to the objective so they could only see and be seen at 6" but could cover the objective with flanking fire. Take a look at that defense. Entire Coy covers objective. 45mm ATG in woods. All dug-in. Artillery BN moved so the area around the objective is within 32" of the ZIS-3. SU-76M as ambush and SU-152 cover the right flank. Infantry reserves come in on the right if you push there and move to far objective and dig-in. KV-8 move to attack any German armor concentration. BN HQ with the 1st Coy for the extra Kommisar. NOTE: Soviet Pioneer Tank Assault is 3 I believe. US and British is 3. Germans are 4.


out dang bot!

Recent Favorites

All-Time Favorites